US Geological Survey

Cover image from WRIR96-4043 (click for enlargement, 55 KB) U.S. GEOLOGICAL SURVEY

Water-Resources Investigations Report 96-4043

Hydrogeology of the Tully Valley and Characterization of Mudboil Activity, Onondaga County, New York

By William M. Kappel, Donald A. Sherwood, and William H. Johnston

CONTENTS

Abstract

Introduction

Study Area

Purpose and Scope

Previous Studies of Mudboils

Acknowledgments

Methods Of Investigation

Surface Water

Stream Discharge

Suspended-Sediment Concentration and Chemical Quality

Ground Water

Water Levels

Water Quality

Precipitation

Test-Well Drilling

Surficial Sediments

Bedrock

Hydrogeology Of The Tully Valley

Bedrock

Stratigraphy

Strike and Dip

Near-Vertical Fracture Patterns

Unconsolidated Deposits

Tully Valley Sequence

Rattlesnake Gulf and Rainbow Creek Sequence

Surface Water

Onondaga Creek Mudboil Corridor

Tributary 6 and Mudboil/Depression Area (MDA)

Discharge

Suspended Sediment

Concentration and load

Particle-size analysis

Chemical Quality

Ground Water

Freshwater Aquifer

Recharge

Discharge

Chemical quality

Brackish-Water Aquifer

Recharge

Discharge

Chemical Quality

Land Subsidence and Landslides

Subsidence from Salt-Solution Mining

Subsidence from Discharge of Mudboil Sediments

Subsidence from Dewatering of Fine-grained Deposits

Tully Valley Landslide

Other Landslides in the Tully Valley

Mudboils

Initial Remediation Efforts

Surface-water Diversion

Mudboil/Depression Area Impoundment

Change in Sediment Concentration and Load

Change in Hydraulic Head

Depressurizing Wells

Mudboil Hydrodynamics

Cause of Mudboils

Onondaga Creek Mudboil Corridor

Natural causes

Human-Induced Causes

Bailey-Loomis dam

Brine field operations

Mudboil/Depression Area (MDA)

Natural Causes

Human-Induced Causes

Brackish-water Discharges

Natural Flow

Human-Induced Flow

Tully Valley Flow Dynamics

Remediation Efforts and Projections

Mudboil/Depression Area (MDA)

Onondaga Creek Mudboil Corridor

Proposed Efforts at Alluvial Fans

Summary

References Cited

Appendixes

1. Historical Timeline - Tully Valley Mudboils

2. Tully Valley Water-quality Data, 1992-94

 

Figures

1. Map of southern Onondaga County, N.Y., showing location and pertinent geographic

features of the Tully Valley, and the trace of geologic section A-A 4

2. Map of Tully Valley N.Y., showing principal geographic features, wells, brine field,

landslides, mudboils, and geologic sections A 1 -A 4 and B-B 1

3. Map of central Tully Valley, N.Y. showing location of wells, Parshall flumes, rain gages, and

geologic sections A 2 -A 3 and B-B‘

4. Geologic section B-B‘ showing major bedrock units below Rattlesnake Gulf and Rainbow

Creek from lower valley walls to top of Vernon Shale

5. Geologic section A-A 4 from Tully Lakes through the middle part of the Tully Valley

showing the position of Salina “F” salt beds, Onondaga Limestone, bedrock surface, and

generalized unconsolidated units in mudboil area near Otisco Road

6. Geologic section B-B‘ showing upper unconsolidated deposits along Otisco Road and deeper

unconsolidated deposits projected from well On-412, southwest of mudboil/depression area

7. Geologic section A 2 -A 3 showing upper unconsolidated deposits in central part of Tully

Valley and projected thickness of freshwater aquifer between wells On-417 and On-435

8. Hydrographs showing daily mean flow leaving mudboil/depression area, water years 1992-95

9. Box plots showing the distribution of daily mean suspended-sediment concentration in MDA

outflow, by month, water years 1992-95

10. Graphs showing total monthly sediment load and total monthly streamflow at

mudboil/depression area outflow for water years 1992-95

11. Map showing estimated average annual artesian-head altitude in freshwater aquifer in

central part of Tully Valley, N.Y.

12. Map showing approximate location of selected springs, ponds, diversion channels, and

south freshwater channel in and near Tully Valley landslide (LS-4) area

13. Map showing extent and depth of brine field subsidence (1957-93) in east and west areas

and along a possible bedrock fracture in southern part of Tully Valley

14. Maps showing development of mudboil/depression area as interpreted from aerial

photographs of 1966, 1978, 1985, and 1991

15. Graph showing monthly recorded precipitation at Syracuse, N.Y. airport, and hydrograph of

water levels at well On-460 showing decreased fluctuations after 90-percent reduction in

salt-solution mining activities in 1986 in western brine field area

16. Hydrographs showing daily mean flow into, and estimated mudboil flow out of

mudboil/depression area, water years 1992-95 A. Inflow. B. Estimated mudboil flow

17. Scatterplots showing relation between suspended sediment concentration and streamflow at

mudboil/depression area before and after remediation measures

18. Box plot showing distribution of suspended-sediment concentrations in water samples from

mudboil/depression area outflow flume before and after remediation efforts

19. Graphs of daily mean suspended-sediment concentration at mudboil/depression area outflow

flume, water years 1992-95

20. Hydrographs showing water levels in monitoring wells downgradient of mudboil/depression-area outlet in relation to water levels controlled by outlet dam, and monthly precipitation

recorded at Otisco Road rain gage

21. Hydrograph showing artesian-head pressure at two monitoring wells On-431 and On-435

35 feet and 195 feet west of depressurizing well On-450, December 1993 through November

1995, and monthly precipitation recorded at Otisco Road rain gage

 

TABLES

1. Atterberg Limits Index results for split-spoon samples taken in test hole On-435, along

Nickols Road near Onondaga Creek, Tully Valley, N.Y.

2. Predominant clay minerals in core samples from selected locations and depths in Tully

Valley, N.Y., in order of decreasing abundance

3. Calculation of discharge from mudboils within the Onondaga Creek mudboil corridor in

Tully Valley, N.Y., 1991-1995

4. Particle-size analyses of selected suspended-sediment samples from the outflow of the

mudboil/depression area Tully Valley, N. Y., 1991-95

5. Median values of selected chemical constituents and physical properties of inflow and

outflow of mudboil/depression area, Tully Valley, N. Y., water years 1992-95

6. Specific conductance and ion concentrations in freshwater samples from selected

sites in Tully Valley, N.Y., water-years 1992-95

7. Concentrations of selected chemical constituents in water samples from mudboils, sulphur

springs, and wells tapping the lower brackish-water aquifer and water-bearing fractures in

bedrock at Tully Valley, N.Y., water years 1992-94

8. Water-quality data from springs and steams draining Tully Valley landslide (LS-4)area,

May 1993 through July 1994

9. Annual discharge, runoff, and precipitation statistics for Tributary 6 watershed areas upstream

and downstream of mudboil/depression area, Tully Valley, N.Y., water years 1992-95, and

corresponding derived statistics for mudboil/depression area


Abstract (HTML format)

Download full PDF report   [Full Report, Acrobat PDF (1.1M)]


Adobe Acrobat's .pdf (portable document file) format can be viewed using the free Adobe Acrobat Reader available for DOS, Windows, Macintosh, and UNIX.

Users with visual disabilities can visit this site for conversion tools and information to help make PDF files accessible.


For more information, contact

U.S. Geological Survey
425 Jordan Rd
Troy, New York 12180
(518) 285-5602
E-mail









To order printed copies, contact

U.S. Geological Survey
Information Services
Box 25286, Federal Center
Denver, CO 80225
1-888-ASK-USGS
E-mail

Return to the New York District Home Page




USGS Water Biology Geology Mapping On-Line Water Resources Investigations Reports On-Line Water-Resources Reports

U.S. Department of the Interior, U.S. Geological Survey
Maintainer: New York District Publications
URL: http://ny.water.usgs.gov/pubs/wri/wri964043/96-4043toc.htm
Last update: 15:14:43 Tuesday 24 April 2001
Privacy Statement || Disclaimer || Accessibility
FirstGov, 'Your First Click to the U. S. Government'